Chinese   |   English
Literature
Tailor made solutions for customers and create more innovative products for them
Your location: Home >> Literature
High-Weatherability Solvent-Borne Nano Pigment Paste (DENSON NA Series) for Automotive Interior and
2026-11-05 01:34:26 Literature

Global automotive OEMs and Tier-1 plastic-parts suppliers no longer specify a colorant for interior and exterior trim by shade alone. They specify a solvent-borne nano pigment paste that stays dispersed through CAB (cellulose acetate butyrate) metallic and electroplated-silver basecoat resins, that does not disturb aluminum-flake orientation or the mirror effect, that survives QUV, xenon-arc and natural-exposure weathering without gloss loss or chalking, that does not bleed or migrate through multi-layer bake systems, and that does not interfere with NCO/OH cure in hydroxyl-acrylic and polyester-modified hydroxyl-acrylic topcoats. For export formulators and NEV (new energy vehicle) paint-line engineers: the high-weatherability route to automotive interior and exterior coloring is the DENSON NA series solvent-borne nano pigment paste, built on high-performance pigments with a polymeric hyper-dispersant, screened against REACH SVHC/azo, RoHS, Directive 2004/42/EC, EU 10/2011, FDA 21 CFR 175.300, GHS/CLP, CBAM, low-halogen (IEC 61249-2-21), phthalate-free and heavy-metal-free positions, with a current SDS and traceable ISO/ASTM/EN/SAE data. Dongguan DENSON Functional Materials Co., Ltd. (DENSON) supplies the NA series through its export arm Dongguan Henvastness Import and Export Co.,LTD.

Benchtop high-speed disperser wetting a deep blue nano pigment concentrate in a 250 mL borosilicate beaker
Figure 1. A benchtop high-speed disperser wets and deagglomerates a deep-blue nano pigment concentrate in a borosilicate beaker. Automotive-grade nano pigment pastes require sub-micron deagglomeration so that the particles remain transparent in clear metallic basecoats and do not scatter light enough to dull the aluminum-flake mirror effect; the NA series is dispersed with a polymeric hyper-dispersant selected for CAB and hydroxyl-acrylic compatibility. Source: Hockmeyer Equipment Corporation benchtop dispersion reference, USA.

1. Introduction: Why Automotive Interior and Exterior Colorants Are Compliance-Critical

Automotive plastic trim is one of the most demanding colorant applications in industrial coatings. Interior parts — instrument panel, door panel, center console, air vents and seat-surround plastics — sit behind the windshield under sustained solar loading and are in contact with skin, cleaning agents, emollients and adjacent soft-touch foams. Exterior parts — bumper, body side trim, mirror housing, grille, door handle and roof rail — are exposed to full UV, dew, road salt, bird droppings, gasoline and washer fluid, and must retain color and gloss over a 10–15 year vehicle life. NEV platforms add longer warranty expectations and paint lines that run both solvent-borne and waterborne booths in the same plant, which forces the colorant supplier to declare its carrier chemistry unambiguously.

A colorant that performs in a general industrial coating can fail in automotive trim for five independent reasons: it flocculates in CAB metallic basecoat and destroys aluminum-flake orientation; it bleeds through clearcoat during bake; it chalks or fades under QUV or xenon; it plasticizes the cured film and drops hardness, impact or crosslink density; or it carries a regulated heavy metal, azo dye, phthalate or SVHC that blocks the OEM RSL. The DENSON NA series is engineered against exactly these five failure modes, and is positioned strictly as a solvent-borne nano pigment paste — it is not waterborne, not solvent-free, and not intended for waterborne, food-contact or low-VOC architectural systems.

2. The NA Series Position: Solvent-Borne Nano Pigment Paste, High Transparency, High Weatherability

The NA series is DENSON's solvent-borne nano pigment paste family. Its three engineering claims are fixed in the technical dossier. First, it is a nano pigment paste: high-performance organic and inorganic pigments are deagglomerated to a sub-micron primary-particle dispersion with a polymeric hyper-dispersant, so that the paste stays transparent in clear and metallic basecoats rather than scattering light like a conventional mill-base. Second, it is solvent-borne: the carrier is a controlled blend of esters, aromatics and ketones matched to CAB, hydroxyl acrylic and polyester-modified hydroxyl acrylic systems; the solvent position is declared per shade in the TDS and SDS and must never be repositioned as waterborne or solvent-free. Third, it is highly weatherable: pigment selection is restricted to lightfastness grade 7–8 (ISO 105-B02) pigments that resist QUV-A/B, xenon-arc and natural Florida/Arizona exposure without chalking, gloss loss or ΔE drift.

Buyers must respect the family boundaries. FLTY is high-solids general coatings but still carries about 20% PMA (CAS 108-65-6) and must never be marketed as solvent-free. RFNC is resin-free but solvent-containing. FLUV and EB are the only truly solvent-free radiation-cure families. PUE is the polyurethane series on a polyether-polyol carrier. UP8 is the styrene-free unsaturated-polyester series for SMC/BMC. NA is the solvent-borne nano series selected for high-transparency, high-weatherability automotive trim; it is never substituted into waterborne, UV/EB or epoxy dossiers. The NA automotive grade is also distinct from the basic NA nano-application grade used in general industrial coloring (Theme 7) and from the resin-free RFNC family used in automotive clear bases (Theme 15): the automotive NA grade carries the full CAB/metallic/weatherability compliance stack below.

Gloss silver metallic hatchback parked in a clean white vehicle-wrap and finishing shop
Figure 2. A glossy silver-metallic finish on a hatchback in a clean finishing shop. Automotive silver and aluminum-flake metallic basecoats depend on every pigment particle being smaller than the flake face and on the hyper-dispersant not adsorbing onto the aluminum surface; the NA paste is screened so it does not cause flocculation, coarsening, or loss of flip-flop and mirror orientation. Source: Arizona automotive finishing shop, USA.

3. No Adverse Effect on Film Performance: Adhesion, Hardness, Flexibility, Impact, Gloss

The first acceptance gate for an automotive colorant is that it does not change the cured film's mechanical envelope. An OEM specifies TPO, PP-EPDM or ABS/PC substrates with a primer, basecoat and clearcoat stack, and the colorant must survive the same adhesion, pencil-hardness, mandrel-bend, impact-reverse and 20°/60°/85° gloss tests as the un-pigmented control. The NA series is screened so that addition of the paste does not: reduce cross-hatch adhesion (ASTM D3359 / ISO 2409, classification 0–1) on treated TPO/PP-EPDM; shift König or pencil hardness beyond the customer's window; cause micro-cracking on mandrel bend (ASTM D522 / ISO 1519); drop reverse or direct impact resistance (ASTM D2794 / ISO 6272); or reduce 20°/60° gloss or cause haze in metallic and solid shades. The hyper-dispersant is chosen so it does not plasticize the network, does not bloom, and does not leave a low-molecular-weight extractable that would later cause intercoat adhesion failure.

4. CAB and Metallic/Electroplated-Silver Basecoat Compatibility: No Flocculation, No Flake-Orientation Interference

CAB (cellulose acetate butyrate) is the workhorse resin of automotive metallic basecoats because it dries fast, controls aluminum-flake orientation and gives the metallic "flip-flop" effect. A poorly dispersed colorant in a CAB metallic basecoat is the most common cause of reject: pigment flocculates around the aluminum flake, the flake stands up instead of lying flat, and the panel loses mirror depth, goes dark at flop, or develops clouding and color travel. The NA series is screened against commercial CAB grades and paired with aluminum-flake and vacuum-metallized ("electroplated silver") pigments. Acceptance is a drawdown and spray-out panel against the customer's standard: no flocculation, no grain, no coarsening on a grind gauge (ASTM D1210 / ISO 1524), no interference with flake orientation, and no dulling of the mirror or liquid-metal effect. Because the NA pigment particles are nano-scale, they sit between the flakes rather than on top of them, preserving the orientation the CAB resin and rotary-bell process establish.

Black textured instrument-panel carrier drying on a stand inside an automotive plastic-parts spray booth
Figure 3. A black textured instrument-panel carrier rests on a stand inside a plastic-parts spray booth after basecoat application. Interior trim — instrument panel, door panel, center console, air vents and seat-surround plastics — demands a colorant that adheres to treated TPO/ABS, does not bleed through contact with foam and skin, and stays low-gloss in the molded texture without chalking under dashboard solar load. Source: Magnific free automotive-interior painting photograph, EU.

5. Weatherability: Low ΔE under QUV, Xenon-Arc and Natural Exposure, No Gloss Loss or Chalking

Exterior automotive trim is the most severe weathering position in industrial coatings. The NA series is pigment-selected for lightfastness grade 7–8 (ISO 105-B02) and tested to the methods OEMs cite: QUV-A/UVA-340 and QUV-B/UVB-313 per ASTM G154 / ISO 4892-3; xenon-arc per ASTM G155 / ISO 4892-2 / SAE J1960 / SAE J2412; and natural Florida or Arizona exposure per ASTM G7 / D4141. Acceptance is a customer-agreed ΔE (CIEDE2000) threshold, 60° gloss-retention floor, and no chalking (ASTM D4214 / ISO 4628-6), cracking (ISO 4628-4), blistering (ISO 4628-2) or fading on the exposed side. Interior parts are additionally heat-aged in a circulating-air oven and checked for combined UV + heat + humidity stress behind the windshield, which fades weak organic pigments even though the part is nominally inside the car.

Q-Lab Q-SUN Xe-2 rotating-rack xenon-arc weathering test chamber with door open showing the specimen carousel
Figure 4. Q-Lab Q-SUN Xe-2 rotating-rack xenon-arc weathering chamber with the door open, showing the vertical specimen carousel around the xenon lamp. Xenon-arc exposure (ASTM G155 / ISO 4892-2 / SAE J1960 / J2412) reproduces the full solar spectrum including visible and infrared, and is the OEM-reference test for exterior bumper, mirror housing, body trim and roof-rail shades; the NA series is screened for low ΔE, gloss retention and zero chalking after the customer's exposure cycle. Source: Q-Lab Q-SUN Xe-2 rotating-rack chamber, Thermoline Scientific product reference, Australia.

6. Solvent Resistance: No Bleeding, Migration, Recolor or Tape-Lamination Failure

Automotive plastic trim is a multi-layer system: primer, basecoat, metallic or effect coat, clearcoat, and sometimes an over-molded TPO or leather skin on top. A colorant that is not solvent-resistant will migrate from the basecoat into the clearcoat during bake, bleed into adjacent soft-foam or PVC skin, recolor a neighboring clearcoat during recoat, or lift under tape lamination and high-temperature end-use. The NA series is screened so that it does not: bleed through a white clearcoat drawdown after bake; migrate into a contacting PVC or polyurethane foam in an oven-migration panel; cause color transfer on a tape-lamination or crocking test; recolor during a force-recoat at the customer's bake window; or leach in contact with gasoline, diesel, washer fluid, suntan lotion or interior cleaners as required by the OEM RSL. Pigment selection is restricted to high-molecular-weight organic pigments (quinacridone, DPP, isoindoline, perylene, metal-complex) and weatherable inorganic pigments with no known blooming or bleeding history in solvent-borne automotive systems.

7. Hydroxyl Acrylic and Polyester-Modified Hydroxyl Acrylic Compatibility: No NCO/OH Cure Interference

The dominant automotive topcoat chemistry today is two-component polyurethane: a hydroxyl-acrylic or polyester-modified hydroxyl-acrylic polyol cured with an aliphatic polyisocyanate (HDI or IPDI trimer). Cure is stoichiometric NCO/OH, and any acid, base, water, alcohol or active-hydrogen impurity in the colorant will shift stoichiometry, leave under-cured surface tack, reduce crosslink density, or drop mechanical and solvent resistance. The NA series is screened so that its hyper-dispersant and carrier are free of cure-active impurities: it does not scavenge NCO, does not introduce water or alcohol, does not shift gel time, and does not reduce crosslink density, König hardness or MEK double-rub resistance (ASTM D5402 / ISO 1517). This is the technical reason the same NA shade can be specified across hydroxyl-acrylic 2K PU, polyester-modified hydroxyl-acrylic 2K PU, and the CAB basecoat underneath, without reformulation.

Clean white downdraft automotive spray booth interior with grated floor, side-wall lights and personnel entry door
Figure 5. Interior of a downdraft automotive spray booth: white side walls, ceiling plenum with filters, grated extraction floor and full-length side lights. Automotive plastic trim is applied by air spray, dip coating and rotary-bell electrostatic spray in booths of this type; the NA paste is thinned to the customer's viscosity window and screened so it atomizes cleanly, does not pull over to grounded plastic parts, and bakes through the OEM cure window without popping, cratering or solvent-pop. Source: Donie Comerford Crash Repair downdraft spray booth, Nenagh, Ireland.

Table 1. DENSON colorant families matched to automotive coating resin, process and carrier position.

Coating positionFamilyCarrier positionAutomotive use
Solvent-borne nano, high transparency, high weatherabilityNA (automotive grade)Solvent-borne ester/aromatic/ketone, polymeric hyper-dispersant, CAB + OH-acrylic compatibleInterior instrument panel / door / console / vents; exterior bumper / trim / mirror / grille / handle / roof rail
Basic nano, general industrial coloringNA (basic grade, Theme 7)Solvent-borne nano, general industrialGeneral industrial; not the automotive CAB/metallic/weatherability grade
Resin-free solvent baseRFNC (Theme 15)Resin-free, solvent + hyper-dispersantAutomotive interior/exterior clear base; not the nano high-weatherability grade
High-solids general coatingsFLTY~20% PMA (CAS 108-65-6)Never "solvent-free"; general industrial coatings
UV / EB coatings and inksFLUV / EBTruly solvent-free, radiation cureUV/EB positions only; not for thermal-bake automotive trim
PU casting / leatherPUEPolyether-polyol, NCO curePU elastomer and leather; not for 2K PU topcoat tinting
UPR gel coat / SMC / BMCUP8Styrene-freeSMC/BMC and gel coat; not for spray-applied trim

8. Parts, Processes and the International Compliance Stack

The NA series is qualified across the parts list and process window that dominate global automotive plastic-trim supply. Interior parts include the instrument panel, door panel, center console, air vents and seat-surround plastics on TPO, PP-EPDM, ABS and PC/ABS. Exterior parts include the bumper, body side trim, mirror housing, grille, door handle and roof rail, typically on TPO or PP-EPDM. Processes include conventional air spray for low-volume work, dip coating for complex vent and handle geometries, and rotary-bell electrostatic spray for high-line-speed OEM bumper and body-trim lines. The bake-cure window is matched to the customer's oven schedule (typically 80–120 °C object temperature for 20–40 minutes on plastic), and the thinner is selected from DENSON's matched solvent blend so viscosity, flash-off and bake-through stay within line specification. NEV plants that run both solvent-borne and waterborne booths must keep the NA paste in the solvent-borne booth: it is not a waterborne product.

Large blue industrial spray-booth and oven installation outside a steel-frame factory building
Figure 6. A large downdraft spray booth and bake-oven installation outside a steel-frame factory. Automotive plastic-trim lines combine a downdraft spray booth, flash-off zone and gas or electric bake oven; the NA paste is thinned to the line viscosity, applied through the agreed atomization process, and baked through the OEM cure window without popping, cratering, solvent-pop or recoat interference. Source: Gel Engineering industrial spray-booth installation, India.

Table 2. NA series multi-part / multi-process compatibility matrix.

PartTypical substrateProcessKey NA demand
Instrument panel, door panel, center consoleTPO, PP-EPDM, ABS, PC/ABSAir spray / rotary-bell, 80–120 °C bakeAdhesion, no migration into foam/skin, heat-aging behind windshield
Air vents, seat-surround plasticsABS, PC/ABS, PPDip coating / air sprayComplex-geometry coverage, no bleed, no skin contact extraction
Bumper, body side trimTPO, PP-EPDMRotary-bell electrostatic sprayWeatherability QUV/xenon, stone-chip, no flake-orientation loss
Mirror housing, door handleTPO, ABSAir spray / rotary-bellGloss retention, solvent resistance to washer fluid and suntan
Grille, roof railABS, PC/ABS, TPOAir spray / dip / rotary-bellLow ΔE under natural exposure, no chalking, no color mismatch
Metallic / electroplated-silver basecoat under clearcoatAny of the aboveBasecoat + clearcoat bakeNo flocculation, no flake-orientation interference, no bleed through clearcoat

The compliance stack below is what automotive OEM and Tier-1 buyers cite most often, and it is the stack DENSON screens the NA paste against before release. REACH (EC 1907/2006) SVHC screening and Annex XVII restrictions, including azo-dye and aromatic-amine limits, are the baseline. RoHS 2 (2011/65/EU) limits Pb, Cd, Hg, Cr(VI), PBB and PBDE for electronic-containing interior positions. Directive 2004/42/EC sets VOC ceilings for coatings and forces an honest declaration of the solvent-borne carrier; the NA paste must never be declared low-VOC or waterborne. EU 10/2011 and FDA 21 CFR 175.300 are referenced only where an interior part is claimed for incidental food or potable-water contact. GHS/CLP (EC 1272/2008) governs hazard labelling: a solvent-borne paste carries H-phrases and pictograms, and the buyer receives a CLP-compliant SDS in the destination language. CBAM raises the embodied-carbon data buyers request across the coating value chain. Low halogen (Br + Cl per IEC 61249-2-21) and phthalate-free, heavy-metal-free positions are declared on the TDS. Methods referenced include ISO 1524 and ASTM D1210 (fineness), ASTM D523 (gloss), ASTM D3359 (adhesion), ASTM D2794 (impact), ASTM D522 (bend), ASTM G154 (QUV), ASTM G155 and SAE J1960/J2412 (xenon), ASTM G7 (natural exposure) and ASTM D4214 (chalking). Dispersion, flake-orientation and weathering science is drawn from Nature, Science, AIChE Journal, Langmuir, Progress in Organic Coatings, Colloids and Surfaces A, ACS and RSC literature, with SAE technical papers for automotive trim exposure.

Table 3. NA automotive-grade export compliance checklist.

Document / datumWhy it mattersTypical reference
REACH Annex II SDSEU customs and downstream Tier-1 auditCurrent ECHA format, destination language
SVHC + azo / aromatic-amine statementREACH candidate list and Annex XVII azo limitsCurrent ECHA SVHC list; no banned azo dye
RoHS conformityInterior parts with electronics (center console, vents)Pb < 100 ppm, Cd < 10 ppm, Cr(VI) free
VOC / solvent declarationDirective 2004/42/EC and NEV paint-shop air permitg/L; solvent-borne position declared per shade
Low-halogen declarationRail / premium-OEM RSLBr + Cl < 900 ppm, IEC 61249-2-21
Phthalate / heavy-metal freeOEM RSL, interior skin-contactDEHP/DBP/BBP/DIBP free; no Pb/Cd/Hg/Cr(VI)
Weathering dataExterior bumper / trim / mirror acceptanceASTM G154 QUV, ASTM G155 / SAE J1960 xenon, ASTM G7 Florida/Arizona
Film-performance dataInterior and exterior trim acceptanceASTM D3359 adhesion, D522 bend, D2794 impact, D523 gloss, D5402 MEK rub
CAB / metallic flake test panelSilver and electroplated-silver basecoat acceptanceNo flocculation, no flake-orientation loss, ASTM D1210 grind gauge
NCO/OH cure compatibility2K PU hydroxyl-acrylic topcoat acceptanceNo gel-time shift, no crosslink-density loss, no surface tack
CBAM / carbon-footprint dataEU border carbon adjustment dossierEmbodied carbon per kg colorant

For OEMs and Tier-1 suppliers preparing automotive interior and exterior trim for global markets, DENSON publishes separate TDS and SDS for the NA automotive-grade series alongside the basic NA nano, RFNC resin-free, FLTY high-solids, FLUV/EB solvent-free radiation-cure, PUE polyurethane and UP8 styrene-free unsaturated-polyester families, and supports qualification against ISO, ASTM, EN and SAE methods. More colorant families and resin-matching guidance are on the DENSON website, and technical literature on nano pigment dispersion, metallic-flake orientation and automotive weathering is collected in the Literature section. Export shipments are handled through Dongguan Henvastness Import and Export Co.,LTD with the REACH, RoHS, CLP, VOC and low-halogen dossiers per consignment.

Key Conclusions

  1. The NA automotive grade is a solvent-borne nano pigment paste, not a waterborne or solvent-free product. It is built on high-performance lightfast pigments with a polymeric hyper-dispersant in an ester/aromatic/ketone carrier, and is positioned strictly for high-transparency, high-weatherability interior and exterior automotive trim. It must not be substituted into waterborne, UV/EB, epoxy or food-contact low-VOC dossiers; FLUV/EB remain the only truly solvent-free DENSON families.

  2. The five engineering claims are fixed and screened. The NA paste (i) leaves film adhesion, hardness, flexibility, impact and gloss unchanged; (ii) is CAB- and metallic/electroplated-silver compatible with no flocculation and no aluminum-flake orientation loss; (iii) shows low ΔE under QUV, xenon and natural exposure with no gloss loss or chalking; (iv) resists bleeding, migration, recoil and tape-lamination failure through multi-layer bake; and (v) does not interfere with NCO/OH cure in hydroxyl acrylic and polyester-modified hydroxyl acrylic 2K PU systems.

  3. Select by part, process and compliance, not by shade. Specify NA automotive grade for instrument panel, door panel, console, vents, seat-surround, bumper, body trim, mirror housing, grille, door handle and roof rail applied by air spray, dip coating or rotary-bell electrostatic spray. Pair it with REACH SVHC/azo, RoHS, 2004/42/EC VOC, GHS/CLP SDS, CBAM, low-halogen (IEC 61249-2-21), phthalate-free and heavy-metal-free documentation, and trace weathering and film data to ISO/ASTM/EN/SAE methods. Never mix NA automotive with the basic NA general grade, RFNC resin-free, FLTY high-solids, PUE, UP8 or FLUV/EB families inside one automotive dossier.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Is the DENSON NA automotive-grade pigment paste waterborne?
No. The NA automotive grade is a solvent-borne nano pigment paste on an ester/aromatic/ketone carrier, and must not be used in waterborne booths or declared as low-VOC. The only truly solvent-free DENSON families are FLUV and EB for UV/EB radiation cure. FLTY is high-solids but still contains about 20% PMA (CAS 108-65-6), and RFNC is resin-free but solvent-containing. For NEV plants that run both solvent-borne and waterborne lines, the NA paste stays on the solvent-borne side.

Q2. Will the NA paste disturb aluminum-flake orientation in a CAB metallic silver basecoat?
No. The NA paste is screened against commercial CAB resins and paired with aluminum-flake and vacuum-metallized "electroplated silver" pigments. The nano-scale pigment particles sit between the flakes rather than on top of them, and the hyper-dispersant does not adsorb onto the aluminum surface; acceptance is verified by spray-out panels against the customer's standard for flop, mirror depth and grind gauge (ASTM D1210 / ISO 1524) with no flocculation or coarsening.

Q3. How is weatherability verified for exterior bumper and mirror-housing shades?
The NA series is pigment-selected for lightfastness grade 7–8 and tested by the OEM-reference methods: QUV-A/B per ASTM G154 / ISO 4892-3, xenon-arc per ASTM G155 / ISO 4892-2 and SAE J1960 / J2412, and natural Florida or Arizona exposure per ASTM G7 / D4141. Acceptance is a customer-agreed ΔE (CIEDE2000) threshold, 60° gloss-retention floor, and zero chalking (ASTM D4214), cracking (ISO 4628-4) or blistering (ISO 4628-2) after the agreed exposure cycle.

Q4. Does the NA paste interfere with 2K PU hydroxyl-acrylic cure?
No. The carrier and hyper-dispersant are screened so they contain no acid, base, water, alcohol or active-hydrogen impurity that would shift the NCO/OH stoichiometry. The paste does not change gel time, does not reduce crosslink density, and does not drop König hardness or MEK double-rub resistance (ASTM D5402) in hydroxyl-acrylic or polyester-modified hydroxyl-acrylic topcoats; sample validation in the customer's own polyol + isocyanate system is still required before type approval.

Q5. Which compliance documents should an automotive buyer request for the NA series?
At minimum: a REACH Annex II SDS, an SVHC and azo/aromatic-amine screening statement, a RoHS conformity statement, a VOC/residual-solvent declaration under 2004/42/EC, a low-halogen (Br + Cl) declaration per IEC 61249-2-21, phthalate-free and heavy-metal-free (Pb, Cd, Hg, Cr(VI)) declarations, weathering data to ASTM G154 / G155 / SAE J1960, film-performance data to ASTM D3359 / D522 / D2794 / D523, a CAB metallic-flake acceptance panel, an NCO/OH cure compatibility statement, and CBAM embodied-carbon data where the customer's product is in scope. EU 10/2011 and FDA 21 CFR 175.300 are referenced only where incidental food or potable-water contact is explicitly claimed.